- Membership
- MAA Press
- Meetings
- Competitions
- Community
- Programs
- Students
- High School Teachers
- Faculty and Departments
- Underrepresented Groups
- MAA Awards
- MAA Grants

- News
- About MAA

Publisher:

Dover Publications

Publication Date:

2003

Number of Pages:

576

Format:

Paperback

Price:

29.95

ISBN:

0486432319

Category:

General

[Reviewed by , on ]

Fernando Q. Gouvêa

05/1/2004

These days, a "manual" is a book that contains instructions, particularly instructions for using a program or a machine. Heath's title, *A Manual of Greek Mathematics*, uses the word in an older sense: "A handbook or textbook, especially a small or compendious one; a concise treatise, an abridgement" (OED). Heath's *History of Greek Mathematics* (also available from Dover) is a massive, two-volume work. In the preface to this *Manual*, Heath says that he expects the larger book to be of interest to classicists (!) and mathematicians, but that he hopes this book will be accessible to members of the general public who are curious about Greek mathematics. He says that besides mathematicians and classicists

"... there is the general reader who has not lost interest in the studies of his youth and would wish to know how it came about that a Greek of the name Euclid wrote a textbook which, in an almost literal translation, was used in schools and in the universities of this country as the one recognized basis of instruction in elementary geometry, and on which generations of Senior Wranglers no less than average mortals were brought up, asking nothing better, until some fifty years ago."

(Ooff! People don't write sentences like that any more!)

He explains that half the book deals with Euclid and his precursors, and then expresses the hope that readers will want to know more: "And who, having got so far, will not wish to know what heights were scaled by Euclid's successors...?" Indeed!

It's not really a criticism of a book first published in 1931 to say that it is old-fashioned. Of course it is. As the preface makes clear, the first publication of the Rhind papyrus, with its revelations about Egyptian mathematics, happened in the 1920s, after the *History* was written and before the *Manual*. Crucial discoveries about the mathematics of ancient Mesopotamia were being made as Heath was writing. And much has happened among scholars of Greek mathematics during the last 70 years.

A particularly noticeable feature of Heath's approach is his exclusive concentration on the content of the major texts. There is very little here about the cultural context in which Greek mathematics was done, very little about the transmission (and reliability!) of the texts, very little about everyday mathematics in ancient cultures.

So while it doesn't count as a criticism, it is still important to say the book is old-fashioned, as a warning to its current readers. By all means use Heath's book, particularly if you would like a quick introduction to the more important mathematical texts. But look for newer books (for example, S. Cuomo's Ancient Mathematics, which despite its title is about Greek, Hellenistic, and Roman mathematics) to fill in the rest of the picture.

Fernando Q. Gouvêa is Professor of Mathematics at Colby College and the co-author, with William Berlinghoff, of *Math through the Ages*.

1.Introductory

2.Numerical Notation and Practical Calculation

3.Pythagorean Arithmetic

4.The Earliest Greek Geometry. Thales

5.Pythagorean Geometry

6.Progress in the Elements Down to Plato's Time

7.Special Problems

8.From Plato to Euclid

9.Euclid

10.Aristarchus of Samos

11.Archimedes

12.Conic Sections

13.The Successors of the Great Geometers

14.Trigonometry: Hipparchus, Menelaus, Ptolemy

15.Mensuration: Heron of Alexandria

16.Pappus of Alexandria

17.Algebra: Diophantus of Alexandria

18.Commentators and Minor Writers

Appendix. Indices.

2.Numerical Notation and Practical Calculation

3.Pythagorean Arithmetic

4.The Earliest Greek Geometry. Thales

5.Pythagorean Geometry

6.Progress in the Elements Down to Plato's Time

7.Special Problems

8.From Plato to Euclid

9.Euclid

10.Aristarchus of Samos

11.Archimedes

12.Conic Sections

13.The Successors of the Great Geometers

14.Trigonometry: Hipparchus, Menelaus, Ptolemy

15.Mensuration: Heron of Alexandria

16.Pappus of Alexandria

17.Algebra: Diophantus of Alexandria

18.Commentators and Minor Writers

Appendix. Indices.

- Log in to post comments