 Membership
 MAA Press
 Meetings
 Competitions
 Community
 Programs
 Students
 High School Teachers
 Faculty and Departments
 Underrepresented Groups
 MAA Awards
 MAA Grants
 News
 About MAA
Most instructors face an uphill battle when teaching mathematics to college students who need to fulfill a math requirement, outside of their major. What topics are suitable? What topics are fundamental? At what level should we teach these topics? These are hard and important questions and each department of mathematics should agree on the appropriate answers according to their student body.
Whatever the answers are, Mathematical Excursions attempts to provide a wide range of topics in mathematics to choose from (see the table of contents for a list) that might be taught in some sort of 100level "Introduction to Mathematics" course. As the authors point out in the preface, "[the book] is similar to an English literature textbook, an Introduction to Philosophy textbook, or perhaps an Introduction to Psychology textbook". The authors also state as a goal the strengthening of the student's quantitative understanding of the world we live in. In that vein, they have included numerous examples and applications throughout the book.
The book is organized as most calculus textbooks (i.e. a brief introduction followed by the main definitions, followed by example — example — example), and each section ends with a large list of exercises. The pages are also sprinkled with "excursions" (extra topics, such as Conway's game of sprouts, or fuzzy sets) and "math matters" pieces and margin notes (explaining the relevance of a given topic in the real world, such as the invention of the Enigma machine). This is a very standard structure. A student who opens this book will be immediately reminded of his/her (often dull) highschool and calculus textbooks.
So, does the book achieve its goals? Yes and no. The book does cover a very wide and varied array of topics, and the authors do a good job at explaining the concepts throughout numerous examples.
The list of topics is varied, but the authors only seem to tap lightly into most of them, and many seem too elementary or even tedious. Chapters 5, 6 and most of 8 (with titles "applications of equations and functions" and "geometry") merely cover highschool level topics, such as solving first and second degree equations; linear, quadratic, exponential and logarithmic functions, and area, perimeter of polygons and elementary trigonometry. The length and elementary nature of such chapters is in stark contrast with other topics. For example, chapter 2 includes an introduction to cardinality (7 pages) and Cantor's diagonalization argument (in one page), while chapter 5 explains how to solve first degree equations in one variable (in over ten pages!).
The biggest problem, however, is the tone. As I pointed out before, I would expect that most of the students enrolled in this class either dislike mathematics, or they fear mathematics, or, at best, the are indifferent about math. In order to reach out to these students, and to capture their imagination and attention, the lecturer needs to transmit the enthusiasm we share for math and explain to the students why mathematics is such an exciting and interesting subject. We need to convey the idea that math is very much alive. Ideally, I would like to have a textbook which already vibrates with such enthusiasm… but "Mathematical Excursions" does not vibrate.
Rating : 1 star (out of three)
Álvaro LozanoRobledo is H. C. Wang Assistant Professor at Cornell University.
