- Membership
- Publications
- Meetings
- Competitions
- Community
- Programs
- Students
- High School Teachers
- Faculty and Departments
- Underrepresented Groups
- MAA Awards
- MAA Grants

- News
- About MAA

In order to answer the Fundamental Question, it is necessary to formulate a definition of connected sets that captures the intuitive notion of continuity in a rigorous and applicable manner. To accomplish this we need two preliminary definitions. First, the *closure* of a set X, denoted by `X, consists of X and all of its limit points. Then we say that two distinct sets A and B are *separated* if neither contains a limit point of the other, that is, if A Ç`B = f and A Ç B = f. For instance, the upper half-plane and lower half-plane are separated. We are now poised to state the definition of connected sets first proposed by the Norwegian-born American mathematician Nels J. Lennes [2].

FUNDAMENTAL DEFINITION: A set of points is connected if it cannot be written as the union of two separated sets.

At heart, this definition expresses connectedness in terms of limit points, so to gain insight into Mullikin’s nautilus we restate an assertion Miss Mullikin made.

MULLIKIN’S LEMMA: Each arc M_{j}contains a limit point of every subset of M which consists of an infinite number of the remaining arcs.

In Mullikin’s Lemma, the intercept x_{j} = (1/2^{j-1}, 0) is a point on the arc M_{j} that is a limit point of every subset of M consisting of an infinite number of the remaining arcs. Click here to see a QuickTime movie demonstrating the convergence geometrically for x_{3} = (1/4, 0).

An understanding of this movie permits one to form the closure `M of Mullikin’s nautilus M = U M_{n}. For if p = (x, 0) with 0 £ x £ 1, then p Î`M. Hence `M = M U I, where I is the unit interval in the plane. Click here to see a QuickTime movie demonstrating this convergence for x = 1/3. Since (1/3, 0) is in`M but not in M, it follows that M is not closed.

David R. Hill and David E. Zitarelli, "Limit Points and Connected Sets in the Plane - Limit Points," *Loci* (August 2010)